Feed on

It’s an old saying but most of us have heard it — “Why buy the cow when you can have the milk for free?” That’s a phrase that’s both dated and sexist, so to hear it re-branded as “cheap sex” — aka casual sex — and purported to be the reason men aren’t committing and marrying is something I would have thought we wouldn’t be discussing in 2017. And yet, here we are, thanks to sociologist Mark Regnerus and his new book, Cheap Sex: The Transformation of Men, Marriage, and Monogamy.

Regnerus (the same sociologist behind a controversial study of how children of same-sex couples fare) says cheap sex — sex with little cost as far as time or emotional investment — is behind a host of societal ills, from fewer people marrying to  the rise of unmarriageable men to more people living together to more children being born outside of marriage — you get the idea. And it’s all because women are giving men sex too easily and quickly, thanks in part to the Pill, without demanding anything in return.

OK, it’s true that fewer young people are marrying nowadays. It’s true that more young people are cohabiting nowadays than ever before. It’s true that the pervasiveness of porn has changed the way men and women think about and engage in sex. And it’s true that there’s a lot more sex outside of marriage nowadays. But to say that the only reason men are avoiding committed relationships and marriage is because women are spreading their legs and giving it up too soon (bad, women, bad!) is shaming, blaming judgmental and, as it happens, not entirely accurate.

‘Men will work for sex’

In a 2011 article in Salon, no doubt the beginnings of his book, Regenerus writes:

(W)hat many young men wish for — access to sex without too many complications or commitments — carries the day. If women were more fully in charge of how their relationships transpired, we’d be seeing, on average, more impressive wooing efforts, longer relationships, fewer premarital sexual partners, shorter cohabitations, and more marrying going on.  … while young men’s failures in life are not penalizing them in the bedroom, their sexual success may, ironically, be hindering their drive to achieve in life. Don’t forget your Freud: Civilization is built on blocked, redirected, and channeled sexual impulse, because men will work for sex. Today’s young men, however, seldom have to. As the authors of last year’s book Sex at Dawn: The Prehistoric Origins of Modern Sexuality put it, “Societies in which women have lots of autonomy and authority tend to be decidedly male-friendly, relaxed, tolerant, and plenty sexy.” They’re right. But then try getting men to do anything. tweet

I have no problem with a society that’s relaxed, tolerant and plenty sexy. In fact, I’m all in! I’m also in for a male-friendly society, too — why not be friendly to men? But, what does it even mean? Does it favor men and men only? In what way? What Regnerus seems to forget or ignores is that some women — not all, but some — would actually like to have casual sex so they can focus on other things besides a romantic relationship, which is a time and energy suck. As my friend, economics professor and Dollars and Sex: How Economics Influences Sex author Marina Adshade, says, women are “shamed for behaving in a way that society believes is contrary to their nature.” People have a hard time believing women can be happy having “cheap sex.” Well, many of us gals actually can.

But Regnerus also seems to say that if men don’t have to work hard for sex, they’re not going to work at anything. Really? I know lots of men who are doing lots of things — working to make the world safer from nuclear weapons, helping poor farmers in Africa and Sudan increase their crops so they can feed their families, investigating fraud, fighting for justice  … Oh, wait — that’s not what Regnerus means; he means try getting them to woo a woman properly and commit and marry. Because I guess that’s the only thing that matters — romantic relationships and marriage. For men like Regnerus, it’s true: they see marriage as a way to make men become respectable members of society, to tame them. But do today’s men really need to be tamed? And, if so, is it really a wife’s responsibility to do that? We have enough on our plate, quite honestly.

And as the mom to two nice young men, one in a committed relationship and one single after five years of a committed relationship, it’s an insult!

Other factors in play

Yes, there are young men who are living in their parents’ basement and playing video games all day, but I highly doubt it’s because women are “giving” them cheap sex — it’s probably more about stagnant wages and the fact that video games offer a social aspect that leads to a boost in guys’ happiness. I don’t fully understand it, but I don’t think convincing women to hold off on providing “cheap sex” is going to do anything Regnerus would like to see happen — like marriage. And some men are wary of marriage because they know divorce is always an option and men haven’t always been treated fairly by family court; why wouldn’t they delay or avoid tying the knot?

And that’s part of what he suggests, that women conspire together to close our legs and vaginas until men give them what they want — even if what we may want is some casual sex until we find the right person to settle down with, if we even want that, and more and more women are just not interested in being married.

Sorry, Regnerus, but it’s not women’s job to control men’s behavior. The guys are going to have to figure this out by themselves. That said, women should never feel that they owe a man sex; we don’t. Ever.

Delaying marriage isn’t all bad

Interestingly, the data Regnerus presents clearly indicates that men are committing and marrying — they’re just waiting longer to do so. But that’s OK! Since we’re living longer than ever and since women fare better by delaying marriage, why are we still wringing our hands about this? Maybe if we offered people other versions of marriage — like time-limited, renewable marital contracts — more would consider tying the knot. Maybe the problem is with our very narrow one-size-fits-all traditional marriage model.

So let’s stop worrying about men getting free milk without buying the cow. As comedian John Mulaney explains, for many men the cow still matters:

Why buy the cow? Maybe because everyday the cow asks you when you’re going to buy it. And you live in a really small apartment with the cow and you can’t avoid that question at all. Also, the cow is way better at arguing than you are. … But for real, why buy the cow? Let’s be real. Why buy the cow? Because you love her. tweet

And that’s what people like Regnerus don’t seem to understand — men will commit to a partner and may even want to marry her (or him or they) when it feels good and right and natural and important and desired. Because sometimes, that’s what they want — even if they’ve had a lively casual sex life with whoever’s given it up freely, willingly and happily.

Want to explore why you want to marry? (Of course you do!) Then read The New I Do: Reshaping Marriage for Skeptics, Realists and Rebels (Seal Press). You can support your local indie bookstore or order it on Amazon.

9 Responses to “Is ‘cheap sex’ making men avoid marriage?”

  1. Rob says:

    I have to agree with you on this one. The reason men aren’t marrying isn’t because of cheap sex. It is because we men have a lot to lose and nothing to gain in the event of divorce thanks to the corrupt, gynocentric family courts in the U.S. Marriage simply offers no benefit to the large majority of men. Why should I get married when I can get anything I want being single? Not only that but if you are a married man your wife controls your sex life. If you are single and your lover loses her libido like most women eventually do you have the choice to boot her out and go find it elsewhere. Married men are stuck unless they want to cheat which is pathetic and something best avoided.

    • Alex says:

      Dear Rob,
      I’m sorry to inform you, someone lied to you. A lot!
      Women don’t normally lose their libido. (specific cases exist, not relevant here)
      They want and love sex
      (not equally to men or other women, we’re all individuals after all)
      They lose interest in men who are not good partners in their everyday life.
      And no one in good marriage controls anybody’s sex life, or anything else.
      Your whole comment is full of sexism, prejudices and misconceptions.
      Going through life with such unfounded representation of reality is sure way to end up unhappy.
      I suggest you doubt what you “know”, try to find out different perspectives and
      ..treat women like humans.

      Happily married feminist*

      Not advocating for marriage. Just some long(er) term healthy & honest partnerships.

      • Rob says:

        Lol, typical delusional feminist claptrap. Try telling this nonsense to all of my non-single friends who are married to women who suddenly lose their libido after trapping the poor guys into marriage. One of my best friends was informed on his wedding night that there would be little or no sex in his future even though she pretended to enjoy it until he put the ring on her finger. She even admitted the deception but he was stuck at that point. No thanks, I’ll happily stay single. If these entitled feminist women want to play games with sex I happily move on to the next.

        BTW, maybe you are happily married but I wonder if your husband is? 😉

        • Alex says:

          What if your circle of friends is just full of sexists like you so you end up with same experiences?
          At no point in your comments you show like you can think for a second that a women is human being, just sex machine.
          Yeah, women buy same lies as you, and they can treat themselves as sex objects too. You have one example, lol, and you sound like he can’t get divorce/annulment. Yeah, just tell yourself those stories are only ones out there.

          I don’t care about you much, as I read your comment to Jono here, and I see you’re beyond repair. Sad.
          And I’m sure you wouldn’t believe me that I know when my husband is happy and when he’s not and why.
          So I can, and do know how he experiences our relationship.
          But your worldview doesn’t include relationships without dishonesty, cheating, exploiting, control… so you’re just going to tell yourself another story why we can’t be true.

          I’m writing this to other possible reader here. Interested in marriage.
          Don’t buy the story about men and women being fundamentally different as people! (those books Mars/Venus type just sell old fashion stereotypes repacked.)
          And be honest. and assertive. Communication is the key.
          Also work on yourself -think about what you want in partner and see to become all that yourself, and you’ll find “like-minded” person.
          Oh, and stay away from people like Rob. Men or women.
          One who can generalize whole gender (or race, nation or whatever large group of different people) can’t see you as a person.

          Have a smart life and/or safe casual sex if that’s your thing.

          • Rob says:

            Reading this kind of judgmental nonsense from a delusional feminist should serve as an example to all of you guys out there as to what you could end up with if you get married to an American woman. There is simply no significant benefit to a man to get married, especially here in the US where you could easily end up with one of these women whose mind has been poisoned by modern feminism. Foreign women are better but still not worth marrying.

            I am still waiting for one of these feminists to tell me one single thing of significance a man can have by getting married that he can’t have by being single. Of course we all know the answer – nothing! Marriage is not good for men, period. So guys just say no to marriage if you want to keep your hard earned money and keep control over your own sex life.

            BTW, my friend whose wife deceived him on his wedding night did a get a divorce and it cost him a million dollars. Yet another glaring example of why marriage is great for women but a horrible deal for men.

  2. Jono says:

    I think plenty of men will make a commitment even if casual sex is available, but commitment isn’t for everyone. With older men I don’t believe casual sex is all that available in general, but it is out there for a price. Rob is right in that married men ARE stuck and then the idea of a renewable contract starts looking very attractive.

    • Rob says:

      Jono, happily you are wrong about older men. I am 62 and I date women 15-20 years younger. There are plenty of them out there who will give it up for free, often on the first or second date, especially if they think that there is a chance that I might eventually commit to them. I have even had success on Tinder with women as young as 36 who were only interested in sex without commitment. It would be even easier if I dated closer to my own age because the over-50 single ladies are, for the most part, pretty desperate but I am not interested in them since I can date younger, more attractive women. The younger ladies also have not lost their sex drive yet and are much more fun in bed than than the older ones, with rare exceptions.

  3. I don’t think casual sex, or any sort of romantic relationship, is necessarily available for men (regardless of their age). Throughout my 20s, I and my male friends all went through long years when any sort of romantic relationship with a woman was very hard to find indeed. Our subjective impression was rather that women were much more in demand than men on the relationship market — or at least, more in demand than we were. Perhaps we were unusual in that respect, but this is the sort of question that an empirical study could try to answer.

  4. Smartest man says:

    This article is a bit late. Men a large portion around the world are avoiding sex altogether. Males to adulthood are constantly observing. They are now observing that sex could make their lives miserable. They see and hear things that they are afraid of and its everywhere. Sex stopping after they are married, Fake rape claims, outrageous tuition costs, divorce settlements highly in favor of the woman, women “sperm jacking”/ stealing sperm and sabotaging birth control, the list goes on and on.
    Men with few exceptions do not want children they just want the sex. Men have always known that women untimely drain a mans wealth and resources for access into her body and to have a raise children. But now the cost has surpassed the levels of wealth and resources he has or is willing to give.
    My proof is everywhere.. Japan’s birth rates are at unsustainable levels for years. South Korea is so desperate for new citizens they are forcing men and women to date. Not due to internet sales bridal shops, toy stores have gone out of business Toys’ᴙ’ Us is about to go down.
    Women have believed nothing is to high to pay for access to her body and her most attractive parts in her underwear. Now they are finding there is a accumulative price that is to high.

Leave a Reply